Imagine this: the Atlanta Braves, a team known for their strategic moves, are facing a critical decision that could shape their future. But here's the twist: their choice at shortstop after 2026 is more complex than anyone anticipated. Let’s dive into why this matters and explore the options on the table.
In hindsight, letting Dansby Swanson go after the 2022 season turned out to be a bigger mistake than initially thought. Since then, the Braves have shuffled through eleven different shortstops, with only Orlando Arcia’s magical 2023 first half standing out as a bright spot. And this is the part most people miss: the position has been a revolving door of mediocrity ever since.
For 2026, the Braves seem set with Ha-Seong Kim on a $20 million salary and Mauricio Dubón as his backup. But here’s where it gets controversial: both players are free agents after this season. Assuming baseball continues in 2027, who will man shortstop for Atlanta? Let’s break it down.
Kim’s one-year deal with the Braves came after he didn’t secure the long-term contract he sought in free agency. Represented by Scott Boras, Kim signed a $20 million deal with Atlanta, a straightforward agreement without the usual contractual complexities. Kim has expressed his desire to improve, particularly in stolen bases, stating, ‘Next year, I naturally think I should run as much as I used to, and I’ll prepare accordingly.’
If Kim returns to his 2023 form, he’ll be one of the most sought-after free agents next winter. Here’s the catch: with the Braves’ ‘Atlanta Max’ salary cap at $22 million, retaining him might be challenging. An early extension could be the solution, but Boras-represented players rarely sign before free agency. However, exceptions exist, like Matt Chapman’s extension with the Giants.
If Kim leaves, Dubón could step in as the everyday shortstop. While his defense is solid, his offense has declined over the years. The real question is: Can Dubón’s versatility—playing multiple positions—help manage the Braves’ injury-prone lineup?
Beyond these two, the free agent market for shortstops is thin. Names like J.P. Crawford and Amed Rosario pale in comparison to Kim. So, what’s the alternative? Trading for a shortstop might be the Braves’ best bet.
Potential trade targets include young players like Jeremy Peña, CJ Abrams, and Zach Neto, or veterans like Corey Seager and Trevor Story. Here’s a wild idea: Matt McLain of the Cincinnati Reds, who, despite recent struggles, could be a valuable addition if he regains his form.
While the Braves have promising prospects like John Gil, Alex Lodise, and Cody Miller, they’re unlikely to be ready by 2027. The bottom line: Atlanta needs a veteran shortstop to remain competitive. Whether through free agency or trade, the Braves must act decisively to secure their future at this critical position.
Thought-provoking question: With the shortstop position so pivotal, should the Braves prioritize an early extension for Kim or explore trades for younger talent? Share your thoughts in the comments—let’s spark a debate!
