The NFL's supplemental draft is an intriguing prospect, offering teams a unique opportunity to bolster their rosters. In this article, we'll delve into the potential acquisition of Brendan Sorsby by the Miami Dolphins, exploring the benefits, risks, and strategic considerations involved.
The Sorsby Scenario
Brendan Sorsby, a former Indiana University and Cincinnati quarterback, finds himself in a peculiar situation. His future with Texas Tech is uncertain due to a gambling addiction, which has led to an NCAA investigation. This could result in Sorsby entering the supplemental draft, where teams can bid for his services with a 2027 draft pick.
Dolphins' Quarterback Conundrum
The Miami Dolphins, having recently signed Malik Willis, are now faced with a decision. Should they consider drafting Sorsby in the supplemental draft? With a quarterback room consisting of Willis, Quinn Ewers, Cam Miller, and Mark Gronowski, the Dolphins' front office is confident in their current roster, but the lack of experience at the position leaves room for improvement.
Strategic Considerations
New GM Jon-Eric Sullivan and head coach Jeff Hafley have expressed their belief in Willis as the franchise quarterback, but the reality is that his limited starts make him an unproven commodity. This opens the door for the addition of a talented prospect like Sorsby. While the Dolphins didn't draft a quarterback in the regular 2026 draft, it's clear that they are open to the idea, especially with the potential to work with Sorsby a year earlier.
Weighing the Risks and Rewards
The question then becomes: what's the right price for Sorsby? Given his talent and potential, he could have been a first-round pick in the 2027 draft. However, the Dolphins must consider their prospects for the 2026 season and the possibility of a high draft pick in the following year. It's a delicate balance between addressing immediate needs and investing in the future.
A Cautious Approach
Personally, I think the Dolphins should proceed with caution. While Sorsby's talent is undeniable, the risks associated with his off-field issues cannot be ignored. Using a first or even a second-round supplemental pick could be too costly, especially considering the team's other needs. A third-round pick might be a more reasonable option, but the Dolphins must be prepared for the possibility of Sorsby being selected earlier.
Learning from History
What makes this particularly fascinating is the Dolphins' past experience with the supplemental draft. In 2005, they selected Manuel Wright, only to see his career cut short due to fitness issues and a public berating by then-head coach Nick Saban. This serves as a reminder that while the supplemental draft offers opportunities, it also comes with its own set of challenges and uncertainties.
Final Thoughts
In my opinion, the Dolphins should approach the Sorsby situation with a strategic mindset. While adding a talented quarterback is tempting, the team must carefully evaluate the risks and rewards. With a balanced approach, the Dolphins can ensure they make the right decision for their long-term success.
